Socrates Refutation of Thrasymachus in Book One of Plato’s Republic: Essay

Sample Essay

Words 1,477

Socrates begins his refutation of Thrasymachus’s position by eliciting Thrasymachus’s sincere conviction that the unjust person always tries to outdo (pleonektein get the better of) everyone in every situation. This admission followed directly by a problematic argument for the claim that justice is associated with cleverness, wisdom, and virtue. Thrasymachus famously responds that he is “not satisfied” with the argument and threatens not to engage in the conversation further unless given the opportunity to reply. He is given no such opportunity and for the most part seems to follow through on his threat.

Thrasymachus always argue with Socrates, either he was wrong or right as Socrates’ present argument for the claim that justice is knowledge and hence virtue is philosophically suspect (i.e., we tend to agree with Thrasymachus that something has gone wrong with that argument), better articulated elsewhere (e.g., the Euthydemus and Gorgias), and — most importantly for this interpretation tangential. The core issue with Thrasymachus is whether justice pays; whether justice is knowledge is a side issue. Note that after giving a long speech explicating his views in the Gorgias Socrates explains why he, nevertheless, does not generally allow his interlocutors to speechify. He says when I made my statements short you didn’t understand and didn’t know how to deal with the answers I gave you, but you needed a narration. So if I don’t know how to deal with your answers either, you must spin out a speech, too. But if I do, just let me deal with them. That’s only fair. (465e-66a)

Thank you for visiting Essaydemon.com and viewing our articles and sample papers. Kindly be informed that all these articles and sample papers are for marketing purposes only. The sole purpose of these articles and sample papers is just to provide our customers with an idea about our services before they place an order.

Kindly visit our order/inquiry page for further assistance.

Kindly order custom made Essays, Term Papers, Research Papers, Thesis, Dissertation, Assignment, Book Reports, Reviews, Presentations, Projects, Case Studies, Coursework, Homework, Creative Writing, Critical Thinking, on the topic by clicking on the order page.

admin

Recent Posts

Maintaining Medical Records

Maintaining Medical Records requires the appropriate software and is essential both for the patients and…

1 month ago

Is Scientology a Religion?

Scientology is regarded the most notorious religious movement of the 20th century. The Church of…

1 month ago

Issues of Capital Punishment

Capital punishment is a contentious and controversial issue in today’s world. The main objective of…

2 months ago

Journalism Ethics and Standards

Journalism ethics and standards comprise are adhered to by journalists. This division of media ethics is commonly called by…

2 months ago

Essay: Shakespeare’s Side of the Story

Sample Essay For Shakespeare’s side of the story, facts were derived from the chronicle by…

2 months ago

Essay: Frankenstein’s Representations

Sample Essay Frankenstein’s representations in movies are however more distorted than the original owner’s intention.…

2 months ago